---
type: reference
domain: history
status: active
updated: 2026-11-14
tags: [shape-of-light, history, verification, sources]
---

# The Shape of Light: history checked against sources

The chapter notes for chapters 7 to 12 and the epilogue listed history written from memory. This note records what was checked on 14 November 2026, against what, and what changed on the pages. "Primary" means the original paper or lecture was read. "Reference" means an encyclopaedia or institutional history, which is good enough for a date or a name and not for an interpretation.

## Chapter 7, The Thermometer Beyond Red

Herschel's three 1800 papers were read in the OCR archive of the *Philosophical Transactions* (jimclifford.ca, from JSTOR 107056, 107057 and 107062).

| Claim on the page | Verdict | Source |
|---|---|---|
| His motive: darkening glasses that gave heat with little light | Confirmed, primary. "I felt a sensation of heat, though I had but little light." | First paper, read 27 March 1800 |
| Results read on 27 March 1800, heating beyond the red | **Corrected.** The 27 March paper found heating rising toward the red. The experiment beyond the red was read on 24 April. | Second paper |
| The thermometer half an inch outside the red rose 8¾ degrees in 16 minutes | Confirmed, primary (new detail on the page) | Second paper |
| He called it radiant heat | Confirmed, primary | First paper, title and text |
| He grew less sure the rays were light | Confirmed, primary, and sharpened. In April he suggested light is the part of radiant heat the eye admits. By November he concluded the rays must be "of a different nature". | Second paper, closing paragraph; third paper, part II, read 6 November |
| More than two hundred experiments | Confirmed, primary. The third paper numbers them to 219. | Third paper |
| Ritter, 1801, silver chloride beyond the violet | Confirmed, reference | Wikipedia, "Johann Wilhelm Ritter" |
| Melloni and Forbes, 1830s: radiant heat reflects, refracts, polarises | Confirmed, reference. The clause about rock-salt prisms was **cut**: likely true, not verified here. | Wikipedia, "Macedonio Melloni", "James David Forbes" |

## Chapter 8, The Window

| Claim | Verdict | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Raman studied the sea "sailing to Europe" in 1921 | **Corrected.** It was on the voyage home, aboard the SS Narkunda, in September 1921, with a pocket spectroscope and a Nicol prism. | Wikipedia, "C. V. Raman" |
| "For much of the nineteenth century the favourite answer" was reflection of the sky | **Softened** to "the accepted answer". The century was not verified. Rayleigh's view is as Raman's own letter reports it. | Raman, *Nature* 108 (1921), not re-read |

## Chapter 9, Windows in the Sky

| Claim | Verdict | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Cornu, 1879: the solar spectrum stops near 300 nm, and the edge moves as the Sun sinks | Confirmed, reference | R. Stolarski, "History of the study of atmospheric ozone", NASA Goddard |
| Hartley, "two years later" | **Corrected** to "soon afterwards". Stolarski gives 1880; the paper is usually cited as 1881. | Same; Wikipedia, "Walter Noel Hartley" |
| Fabry and Buisson, 1913 and 1920 to 1921; a layer a few millimetres thick | Confirmed, reference. Sources give 3 mm and 5 mm for their figure; "a few millimetres" covers both. | Stolarski; Wikipedia, "Ozone layer" |
| Dobson, 1920s, the spectrophotometer and the unit | Confirmed, reference | Stolarski; Wikipedia, "Dobson unit" |

## Chapter 10, The Size of a Dish

| Claim | Verdict | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Jansky: 20.5 MHz, 14.6 m, about 30 m long, Ford Model T wheels, a turn every twenty minutes, Holmdel | Confirmed, reference | NRAO, "Jansky's Experiment" and archive documents; Wikipedia |
| *New York Times* front page, 5 May 1933; Bell Labs moved him to other work | Confirmed, reference | NRAO legacy page; AIP history |
| Reber's dish "in his mother's back yard" | **Corrected** to "his back yard". No source calls it his mother's. | Green Bank Observatory, "Reber Telescope" |
| Reber found the galaxy "in 1939" | **Corrected** to 1938, after failing at two shorter wavelengths. The dish was 31.4 ft, which is 9.6 m. | Same; Wikipedia, "Grote Reber" |
| Ewen and Purcell 1951; van de Hulst 1944; Ryle's Nobel Prize 1974 | Confirmed, reference | Wikipedia, "Hydrogen line", "Martin Ryle" |
| Michelson "put two mirrors six metres apart" | **Corrected** to "up to six metres apart". The beam was 20 ft; Betelgeuse's fringes vanished at 121 in. | Michelson and Pease (1921), as in chapter 3's note |
| EHT: April 2017, eight telescopes, published 2019; M87 at 55 million light years, 6.5 billion solar masses | Confirmed against the collaboration's figures (16.8 Mpc). Wikipedia's M87 article gives 16.4 Mpc. | EHT Collaboration, *ApJL* 875 (2019), as cited |

## Chapter 11, A New Kind of Ray

| Claim | Verdict | Source |
|---|---|---|
| 8 November 1895; the barium platinocyanide screen; the paper of 28 December; no patent; Nobel Prize 1901 | Confirmed, reference | Wikipedia, "Wilhelm Röntgen" |
| His wife's hand, 22 December; reprints with photographs posted on 1 January 1896 | Confirmed, reference | Wikipedia, "X-ray"; historyofinformation.com |
| Physicists "from Manchester to New Hampshire" | Confirmed, reference: Schuster in Manchester (Wellcome record), Frank Austin at Dartmouth, January 1896 | Wikipedia, "X-ray" |
| 1962 rocket, about five minutes above the air; Sco X-1 a thousand times brighter in X-rays than in visible light | Confirmed, primary. "Five minutes above 100 km"; "the x-ray luminosity is 10³ times the visible light intensity." | R. Giacconi, Nobel lecture (2002) |

## Chapter 12, The Hardest Light

| Claim | Verdict | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Villard, 1900, radium; Rutherford's name, 1903; Rutherford and Andrade, 1914 | Confirmed, reference | Wikipedia, "Gamma ray", "Paul Ulrich Villard" |
| Compton, 1923, Washington University: molybdenum Kα X-rays scattered from graphite; Nobel Prize 1927 | Confirmed, reference | HyperPhysics, "Compton scattering data"; Wikipedia, "Compton scattering" |
| Klein and Nishina "worked out in 1929" | **Corrected** to "published in 1929". They derived it in 1928. | Wikipedia, "Klein–Nishina formula" |
| "After Compton, light's push was no longer a matter of opinion" | **Corrected.** Bohr, Kramers and Slater tried once more in 1924. The Bothe–Geiger and Compton–Simon experiments of 1925 settled it. The page now says so. | Wikipedia, "Bothe–Geiger coincidence experiment", "Photon" |
| Most physicists, Planck and Bohr among them, doubted light quanta for nearly twenty years | Confirmed in substance, reference | Wikipedia, "Photon" |

## Epilogue

The seventeen timeline entries were checked for date and attribution against reference articles: Ibn al-Haytham (*Book of Optics*, 1011 to 1021, Cairo), Grimaldi (1665), Huygens (1690), Newton (1704), Herschel and Ritter, Young, Fresnel and Arago with Poisson's spot (1818 to 1819), Foucault (1850), Maxwell (1865), Hertz, Röntgen, Planck, Einstein, Taylor (a three-month exposure), Compton, quantum electrodynamics (Nobel Prize 1965), and Grangier, Roger and Aspect (read in full for chapter 5). All stand.

Present-day claims: dark matter as about 85% of matter, the microwave background at about 380,000 years, and the 2018 EDGES signal that SARAS 3 did not confirm in 2022 are confirmed by reference. The rest were checked the same way and stand:

| Claim | Source (Wikipedia unless noted) |
|---|---|
| The first fast radio burst found in 2007 by Lorimer; one traced to the magnetar SGR 1935+2154; a burst releases in a millisecond what the Sun does in days | "Fast radio burst": "as much energy in a millisecond as the Sun puts out in three days" |
| Super-resolution microscopy, Nobel Prize in Chemistry 2014 | "Super-resolution microscopy" |
| A clock comparison across one millimetre of height (2022); the second likely to be redefined with optical clocks | "Atomic clock" |
| Entangled photons shared over 1,200 km by satellite (2017) | "Quantum Experiments at Space Scale" |
| Gravitational waves first detected on 14 September 2015 by interferometers with 4 km arms; a length change of a few thousandths of a proton's width | "First observation of gravitational waves". The page's figure is 4 × 10⁻¹⁸ m over 4 km, about 1/400 of a proton's diameter. |
| JWST galaxies from the universe's first few hundred million years | "JADES-GS-z14-0": about 300 million years after the Big Bang |
| Pit vipers strike warm prey from tens of centimetres (chapter 8) | "Infrared sensing in snakes" gives detection from several metres, so the page's figure is conservative |

## Chapters 2, 8, 10 and 12: history added on 14 November

New sentences on Zernike (chapter 2), on pigment noise (chapter 8), on Hertz (chapter 10), and on Dirac, Anderson, Blackett and Occhialini (chapter 12) are sourced in those chapters' notes.

## The third room, chapters 13 to 15

The history in the three chapters of Inside the Lamp was checked as each was written, on 14 November 2026. The tables are in [[ch13-science-and-testing]], [[ch14-science-and-testing]] and [[ch15-science-and-testing]]. Six statements were cut or changed against the sources: Planck's phrase is quoted as "an act of despair", as the source read gives it; a figure for Betelgeuse's temperature, a figure for tungsten's emissivity, the year COBE's instrument stopped, a superlative about Fraunhofer and a "million times" attributed to Cecilia Payne were all cut for want of a source read. The epilogue's timeline gained one entry, Bohr in 1913, and its entries for Planck and for quantum electrodynamics now point to chapters 13 and 15.

## Round seven: original papers read, and a references page

Daniel asked for the original papers behind the third room to be read, and for the references of the whole project to be visible. Read on 14 November 2026: Kirchhoff and Bunsen (1860, abridged translation), Planck (1901, translation), Planck's Nobel lecture (1920), Bohr (1913, part I), Feynman's Nobel lecture (1965), Casimir (1948), and Aoyama, Hayakawa, Kinoshita and Nio (2012), with the abstracts of Fixsen and colleagues (1996) and of Fan and colleagues (2023). What each added to a page is recorded in the notes for chapters 13 to 16. Nothing read contradicted a page. One figure on a page is now checked against a figure printed in an original paper: the Casimir pressure at one micron.

Tried and not obtained: Balmer (1885), Michelson and Morley (1887), Dirac (1927), Einstein (1905), each refused or rate-limited by the archive that holds it. They are marked "cited" on the references page.

The page `site/references.html` lists every source by chapter with one of four marks: read, abstract, cited, account. It is linked from the front door, the epilogue, "How this was made", and the source notes of chapters 13 to 16.

## The fourth room, chapters 17 to 21, and the prizes (15 November 2026)

Each chapter of the fourth room carries its own table of claims, sources and corrections in its science and testing note: [[ch17-science-and-testing]], [[ch18-science-and-testing]], [[ch19-science-and-testing]], [[ch20-science-and-testing]] and [[ch21-science-and-testing]]. Read in the original for the room: Newton's *Opticks* (Project Gutenberg's text of the fourth edition), the Nobel lectures of Wald and Hartline (1967) and of Hubel (1981), and Strasburger, Rentschler and Jüttner's review of peripheral vision (2011). Read as abstracts: about twenty papers, listed with that mark on the references page. Everything else is from encyclopaedia articles, named in each note.

In all, about twenty sentences of the first drafts went beyond what the sources read could support and were cut back or removed. The pattern was the same each time: a vivid detail remembered from somewhere (that Klüver took the drug himself, that the Apollo crews had their eyes shut, that viewers who missed the gorilla "looked straight at it") which the source actually read did not contain. Each is recorded in the chapter's note under the claim it belonged to.

The Nobel Prizes are a different kind of claim and are checked a different way. Every name and citation on the prizes page, and every citation quoted in a chapter, is copied by a script from the Nobel Foundation's records (`data/nobel/nobel-prizes.json`, fetched from the Foundation's data service on 15 November 2026) and compared with them again by `tests/prizes_check.py`. Three facts on that page are not in the records and come from encyclopaedia articles: that the Cherenkov effect is light, that computer assisted tomography makes its pictures with X-rays, and that LIGO stands for Laser Interferometer Gravitational-Wave Observatory.

One change to an earlier chapter: chapter 16 no longer ends the exhibition. Its closing now leads into the fourth room.

## What this pass did not do

It did not read Raman's 1921 letter, Cornu's, Hartley's or Jansky's own papers, or a scholarly life of Röntgen. Where a page states an interpretation rather than a date, it now rests on a primary source (Herschel, Giacconi) or has been softened.
